Part 19: Monetary Reform: Series 1

Difficult conversation, continued:

Joe Bongiovanni,

Okay, now I see where the confusion is.

Of course I saw:

"(b) Technical and Conforming Amendment to the FDIA- Section 3(l) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813(l)) is amended by adding at the end the following:

"'Such term does not include any amount on which any interest is paid or which is received or held by a bank or savings association pursuant to a loan agreement for a fixed term of time (as determined without regard to any designation on the agreement as a loan, certificate, or other particular instrument).'."

I didn't tack it on [you wanted less but are requiring more] in my last go around with you. I plugged it in mentally the first time I read the whole Act, which I've done several times. For you though, let's add it verbatim according to the Act so everyone may see exactly what happens and what it does in reality and not just your mind, Joe.

Here's the end:

"(5) such other obligations of a bank or savings association as the Board of Directors, after consultation with the Comptroller of the Currency, Director of the Office of Thrift Supervision, and the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, shall find and prescribe by regulation to be deposit liabilities by general usage, except that the following shall not be a deposit for any of the purposes of this chapter or be included as part of the total deposits or of an insured deposit:
...
"(C) any liability of an insured depository institution that arises under an annuity contract, the income of which is tax deferred under section 72 of title 26.

"Such term does not include any amount on which any interest is paid or which is received or held by a bank or savings association pursuant to a loan agreement for a fixed term of time (as determined without regard to any designation on the agreement as a loan, certificate, or other particular instrument)."

What designation does that take in that position? Answer: § 1813(l)(5)(D). What does that mean?

"...except that the following shall not be a deposit for any of the purposes of this chapter or be included as part of the total deposits or of an insured deposit: [however] Such term does not include any amount on which any interest is paid or which is received or held by a bank or savings association pursuant to a loan agreement for a fixed term of time (as determined without regard to any designation on the agreement as a loan, certificate, or other particular instrument)."

It's a negation. Time deposits become deposits become transaction accounts under the NEED Act. I took it as more mess, which it is, for the reason I give below, not that the Act is not a good beginning, as I've said in this thread. If it weren't a good start, I would never have been here spending all this time on it.

I haven't had the time to work through the entire document all by myself, as I work full-time (actually more). That's why I've been asking for help, while you, Joe, have been assuming (acting as if) the bill is perfect, which is clearly not the case, and have made this all take exceedingly longer than it should.

You're giving it the designation "§ 1813 (l)(6)" in your mind. That's the only way it can accomplish what you want (though it's still poorly/awkwardly worded). Now, if you want it to be "(6)," then put that in the NEED Act as follows (and don't moan about it or lick your wounds; just get over it – better yet, don't take it personally in the first place):

"(b) Technical and Conforming Amendment to the FDIA- Section 3(l) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813(l)) is amended by adding at the end the following:

"(6) 'Such term "deposit" does not include...."

I added "deposit" for additional clarification, as "(l) Deposit
The term "deposit" means—."

Frankly {since this NEED Act is amending 1813 (l)}, it should actually read thusly rather than simply prefixing it with (6):

"(b) Technical and Conforming Amendment to the FDIA- Section 3(l) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813(l)) is amended as follows:

"(l) Deposit
(1) Subject to 1813 (l)(2), the term "deposit" means—
[whole thing here with new outline designators]
(2) The term "deposit" does not mean—
(A) any amount on which any interest is paid or which is received or held by a bank or savings association pursuant to a loan agreement for a fixed term of time (as determined without regard to any designation on the agreement as a loan, certificate, or other particular instrument)."

Either way, you change the Act's wording.

This is what collaboration is about. It is not about your sarcasm, as if you arrived at some gotcha moment. You didn't arrive there and shouldn't have wanted to in the first place.

Focus on fixing things. It would have been an easy matter for you to have said very politely, Tom, take a look at ... to see if it ... whatever. That's the style I'm used to. Then it would be an easy matter for me to reply, I think it would improve things if .... Then you'd say, good idea/clarification/edit or have you considered.... [something other than that I wasted all my time copying and pasting – I haven't; but knowing you,..].

Tom

P.S. I will not be posting here for a few days at least, as I have a day job and a night job.

Monetary Reform: Series 1

  • Subscribe


  • Tom Usher

    About Tom Usher

    Employment: 2008 - present, website developer and writer. 2015 - present, insurance broker. Education: Arizona State University, Bachelor of Science in Political Science. City University of Seattle, graduate studies in Public Administration. Volunteerism: 2007 - present, president of the Real Liberal Christian Church and Christian Commons Project.
    This entry was posted in Libertarian Capitalism, Monetary Reform, United States Notes. Bookmark the permalink.